Fresh Baked Italian-American Cookies — Handcrafted with Love
Assorted containers and gift trays, perfect for celebrations, gifting, or a sweet treat for yourself!
How It Works
1. Choose Your Cookies
Browse our Cookie Family and pick your favorites — from classic butter cookies to sprinkle-topped showstoppers.
2. Place Your Order Online
Add them to your cart and check out before the end of the ordering period. Every order is baked fresh, just for you.
3. Pick Up & Enjoy
Come by on pickup day, take home your cookies, and share the sweetness with family & friends.
Meet the Cookies Family
We’re not just cookies — we’re the Cookie Family! Some of us are bright and citrusy, others are nutty and sweet, but all of us are handcrafted with love! We may be different, but we belong together…. and we’d love to find a place at your table. Come meet us individually below (but be warned — you’ll fall in love with more than one of us).
Our classic Italian Butter Cookies — tender, melt-in-your-mouth, and baked with love! These little gems are the heart of every cookie container, and now you can choose your favorite style:
✨ Plain – buttery perfection, no frills needed.
🌈 Rainbow Sprinkles – dipped in chocolate, covered in festive sprinkles.
🍫 Chocolate Sprinkles – dipped and finished with a chocolatey crunch.
🍫 Dipped – simple, elegant, just chocolate and cookie.
🍪 Chocolate Chip – the same rich dough dotted with mini chocolate chips.
Whether you like them dressed up or kept classic, each bite is butter nostalgia. Perfect for sharing, gifting, or keeping all to yourself (we won’t tell!)
While few of our toppings (like candied cherries or sprinkles) may contain preservatives, every single cookie we bake is made fresh with no added preservatives. Because of that, our cookies best enjoyed within 3 days of pick-up for peak flavor and texture.
Cookies may contain or come in contact with common allergies, such as wheat, milk, eggs, and tree nuts.
ORDER NOW TO GET YOUR SPECIAL TREAT!
Share the sweetness of fresh-baked tradition with a gift card to the Bakery. Perfect for birthdays, holidays, thank you, or just because — our gift cards let your loved ones choose from our full selection of Italian cookies and treats. Whether they’re craving a classic assortment, a special tray for gatherings, or something new to try, a gift card is the easiest way to give the gift of homemade flavor and joy
Send the joy of an Italian bakery with our beautifully arranged Italian Cookie Gift Tray. Each tray is packed with a hand-picked assortment of favorites:
Bite-sized lemon, cherry, orange & almond Anginetti cookies
Classic S cookies
Buttery snowballs
Chewy almond paste cookies
Spiced meatball cookies
Colorful rainbow cookies
Perfect for birthdays, holidays, or any special occasion, this gift-ready tray brings the warmth and tradition of fresh-baked Italian cookies straight to the table.
While few of our toppings (like candied cherries or sprinkles) may contain preservatives, every single cookie we bake is made fresh with no added preservatives. Because of that, our cookies best enjoyed within 3 days of pick-up for peak flavor and texture.
Assortments have cookies with common allergies, such as wheat, milk, eggs, soy, and tree nuts.
Freshly baked each drop — order your tray today and delight someone special!
Why choose just one? Our assorted container brings together the very best of our bakery classics, all in one box. Inside you’ll find:
Classic Bite-Sized Anginetti in Lemon, Cherry, Orange & Almond
Traditional S Cookies
Meatball Cookies (a rich, spiced Italian favorite)
Powdery Butterballs
Almond Paste Cookies (chewy, nutty perfection)
Rainbow Cookies (layered almond sponge with jam & chocolate)
This container is made for sharing at home, bringing to the office, or treating yourself when you can’t decide which cookie you’re craving.
Note: This is our everyday assorted container, not the decorative gift tray.
While few of our toppings (like candied cherries or sprinkles) may contain preservatives, every single cookie we bake is made fresh with no added preservatives. Because of that, our cookies best enjoyed within 3 days of pick-up for peak flavor and texture.
Assortments have cookies with common allergies, such as wheat, milk, eggs, soy, and tree nuts.
Don’t wait — secure your cookies now
Why Our Cookies Are Special
We’re not just cookies — we’re a taste of tradition. Every bite comes from recipes passed down through generations, lovingly baked in small batches with simple, honest ingredients. That means no shortcuts, no factory lines, just the kind of care you’d expect from a family kitchen.
What makes us truly special is the way we bring people together. Our cookies aren’t just treats — they’re memories in the making, the centerpiece of family gatherings, and the sweet surprise in someone’s day. Whether you grew up with Italian cookies or you’re discovering them for the first time, we’re here to share the joy, one batch at a time.
